01. Miscarriages of Justice Registry

/

Case: William Smith

2019

Conviction overturned

Optional Sidebar title text

Table of Contents

Description
William Smith was convicted (in his absence) in June 2011 at Belfast Magistrates Court in relation to a drink driving offence. The offence itself was committed in July 2005. He was fined £400 and banned from driving for 12 months. On 31st December 2011, Mr Smith was arrested due to non-payment of the fine and spent six days in Maghaberry jail. Mr. Smith later tried to appeal, but his application was rejected. In March 2015, he applied to the CCRC. The CCRC found evidence showing he was not the driver of the car who had failed a breathalyser test in July 2005. Mr Smith had never held a full driving licence. There were also errors in the trial and post-conviction process. These errors stopped Mr. Smith from defending himself or being able to apply for an extension of time in which to seek leave to appeal. In February 2019, the CCRC referred the case. The County Court quashed the conviction in May 2019.
Expand All

Overview

Jurisdiction

Northern Ireland

First & Last Name

William
Smith

Gender

M

Ethnicity

Unknown

Age When Imprisoned

Age When Released

Years in Prison

Compensation

Compensation Paid

Compensation Link

Compensation Type

Compensation Amount

Dates

Year of Crime

2005

Year of Conviction

2011

Year Conviction was Overturned

2019
Excerpt

Research information

Reference

Link to Full Case

Offences

Offence

Other

Offence Convicted Of

Drink Driving

Most Serious Offence

Other

Courts

Factors Involved

Guilty Plea

Tried with Others

Retrial

Majority Verdict

Unanimous Verdict

Evidence

Type of Witness Evidence

Affirmative Evidence of Innocence

Fresh Evidence

CCRC Referral

Yes

Neutral Citation

Crown Argued Case at CofA

Previous Appeals

1

Number of Previous Applications

Legal Representation on Appeal

Patricia Coyle of Harte Coyle Collins Solicitor

Is Post Office Case